Simon Lopez, left, and Hiliaro Islas try to collect signatures this week in Phoenix in an effort to recall Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio. The recall effort failed Thursday. (Matt York / Associated Press / May 29, 2013)
TUCSON — Despite a recent court ruling that the department run by Maricopa County’s top cop used racial profiling in his quest to crack down on illegal immigration, a recall effort against Sheriff Joe Arpaio has failed.
On Thursday, members of Respect Arizona and Citizens for a Better Arizona — who launched the recall effort against Arpaio — failed to gather the necessary 335,000 valid voter signatures by the 5 p.m. deadline. The aim was to force a recall election.
Activists behind the recall effort would not say how many signatures they were short. Randy Parraz, president of Citizens for Better Arizona, only said the two groups had collected close to 300,000 signatures.
Arpaio, reelected in November, blasted the group in a prepared statement.
“After months of name calling, after the disparaging effigies and theatrics … this latest recall effort has failed,” Arpaio said. “This effort failed because the good people of Maricopa County, whom I’m honored to serve, rejected the wrongheaded idea of overturning an election.”
The groups had struggled to raise funds necessary to hire paid signature gatherers – key to these sort of efforts. Instead, the groups relied heavily on volunteers to gather signatures against the six-term sheriff who is something of an institution in Arizona’s largest county.
Parraz, who led a successful recall against state Senate President Russell Pearce two years ago, said Thursday’s setback wouldn’t stop Arpaio’s critics.
“This fight is not over,” Parraz said.
The groups gained momentum after a federal judge ruled Friday that the immigration enforcement policies employed by Arpaio violated the Constitution.
Judge Judge G. Murray Snow found that Arpaio’s deputies used racial profiling when they detained people they suspected of residing in the country illegally.
The 142-page ruling came as part of a lawsuit brought on behalf of Latino plaintiffs who accused the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office of using race as a major factor in initiating immigration enforcement stops.
Arpaio has promised to appeal the ruling.
Parraz said the movement was “vindicated” by Snow’s ruling and plans to put pressure on the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors not to fund Arpaio’s appeal.
//////////////////////////
-
3:43
1
Feb. 13, 2013 UPDATE BREAKING – Obama Identity Scandal – Lt. Mike Zullo
by ppsimmons 60,711 views
-
2:38
2
Chris Matthews Race-Baiting J.C. Watts With Obama Birth Certificate Scandal
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,036 views
-
2:38
3
Chris Matthews Race-Baiting J.C. Watts With Obama Birth Certificate Scandal
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,036 views
-
4:06
4
Michael Lerman Serves California Elected Officials & Electors Obama Treason Notice
by BirtherReportDotCom 12,482 views
-
7:00
5
Sheriff Joe Arpaio: I Want To Know About Obama’s Forged Identity Documents; Slams Congress/Media
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,744 views
-
6:32
6
Sarah Palin: Obama Is A Socialist; After Socialism Comes Communism
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,521 views
-
1:34
7
Mark Levin: Will Obama’s Presidential Library Be In Chicago Or In Kenya?
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,922 views
-
9:26
8
Greta & Palin Rip Obama Admin & Media Over Benghazi Cover-Up
by BirtherReportDotCom 892 views
-
2:05
9
Rep. Louis Gohmert: Obama Admin Has Muslim Brotherhood Members Advising Them
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,081 views
-
1:07
10
Jamie Foxx: Give Honor To God And Lord & Savior Barack Obama
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,195 views
-
3:55
11
Little Old Lady Goes Birther On CNN Hitman Reporter Gary Tuchman
by BirtherReportDotCom 12,634 views
-
2:21
12
Senior Editor of Foreign Policy Magazine: Obama Born In Kenya – 11/13/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,606 views
-
3:42
13
Rep. Southerland On Obama’s Identity Fraud: Blames Harry; The “People” Need To Impeach Obama?
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,825 views
-
1:13
14
Sen. Bob Menendez on Secret Service Prostitution Scandal: Fire Them!
by BirtherReportDotCom 923 views
-
1:48
15
Insane Obama: Romney’s Policies Would Have Made My Birth Certificate More Expensive
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,593 views
-
3:15
16
Fox News’ Kimberly Guilfoyle & Sean Hannity Rip Obama Not Releasing Records
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,974 views
-
12:38
17
David Letterman Audience Wants Obama To Release College & Passport Records – 10/25/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 33,332 views
-
2:26
18
Obama On Trump Feud: Dates Back To When We Grew Up Together In Kenya – 10/24/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,734 views
-
8:31
19
Trump Rips Greta A New Obamahole Over $5 Million Dollar Obama Records Challenge – 10/24/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 11,266 views
-
2:45
20
Ann Coulter: Donald Trump’s $5 Million Obama Records Challenge – 10/24/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,443 views
-
1:32
22
Romney Highlights Foreigner Obama’s Foreign Investments: Obama Ducks & Weaves – 10/16/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,498 views
-
0:40
23
Son of Governor Tommy Thompson: We Can Send Obama Back To Kenya.wmv
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,597 views
-
7:57
24
GAI Investigators: Foreign Nationals Illegally Donating To Obama Campaign – Part 1
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,229 views
-
8:44
25
GAI Investigators: Foreign Nationals Illegally Donating To Obama Campaign – Part 2
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,341 views
-
3:21
26
MSNBC Goes Rogue: Debate Was Obama’s Emperor Has No Clothes Moment
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,943 views
-
3:49
27
Robert Gibbs: Real Jobs Report In Nairobi With Obama’s Kenyan Birth Certificate
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,597 views
-
3:04
28
Trump on Greta: Obama Passport Records, College Records, Born in Kenya Bio – 10/2/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,716 views
-
5:07
29
Trump and Hannity Discuss Obama’s Forged Birth Certificate And Missing College Records
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,354 views
-
3:02
30
Ann Coulter: Birther Issue Has Nothing To Do With Obama Being Black – 9/28/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,634 views
-
1:03
31
Madonna: We Have A Black Muslim In The White House – 9/24/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,901 views
-
13:12
32
Pamela Geller Takes CNN’s Erin Burnett To The Woodshed Over Obama’s Birth Certificate & Jihad
by BirtherReportDotCom 18,714 views
-
5:53
33
Fox News Reports Barry Soetoro’s Manufactured Past; Michelle Obama’s DNC Lies
by BirtherReportDotCom 9,515 views
-
15:04
34
Journalist Mark Tapscott Obliterates Obama’s Manufactured Past
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,518 views
-
15:07
35
Joel Gilbert Punks Media: Mails 1,000,000 DVDs To Ohio Voters – 9/19/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,914 views
-
15:08
36
Joel Gilbert Has Major Announcement About Dreams From My Real Father Movie – Part 1 of 2
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,383 views
-
5:11
37
Joel Gilbert Has Major Announcement About Dreams From My Real Father Movie – Part 2 of 2
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,511 views
-
0:34
38
Freudian Slip: Obama Now Says He Was Born To Single Mom; No Goat Herder? – 9/13/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 27,378 views
-
13:08
39
Joel Gilbert Discusses Dreams From My Real Father: Blasts The Media’s Cover-Up – Part 1 of 3
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,210 views
-
14:21
40
Joel Gilbert Discusses Dreams From My Real Father: Blasts The Media’s Cover-Up – Part 2 of 3
by BirtherReportDotCom 829 views
-
11:11
41
Joel Gilbert Discusses Dreams From My Real Father: Blasts The Media’s Cover-Up – Part 3 of 3
by BirtherReportDotCom 692 views
-
2:12
42
Sean Hannity Bans Obama Eligibility And Forged Birth Certificate Callers
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,410 views
-
14:29
43
Sheriff Joe’s Lead Investigator: No Proof Obama Was In Hawaii As Baby – Part 1 of 4
by BirtherReportDotCom 12,235 views
-
12:39
44
Sheriff Joe’s Lead Investigator: No Proof Obama Was In Hawaii As Baby – Part 2 of 4
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,754 views
-
13:14
45
Sheriff Joe’s Lead Investigator: No Proof Obama Was In Hawaii As Baby – Part 3 of 4
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,558 views
-
9:37
46
Sheriff Joe’s Lead Investigator: No Proof Obama Was Born In Hawaii – Part 4 of 4
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,893 views
-
1:25
47
Bill Clinton at DNC: Republicans Convinced Me They’re Grateful They Were Born In America
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,758 views
-
2:03
48
Democrat Santita Jackson On Obama’s Records: Transparency Is A Legitimate Request
by BirtherReportDotCom 748 views
-
11:15
49
WND’s Bob Unruh Discusses Democrats Certification Of Nomination For Ineligible Obama
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,265 views
-
5:58
50
Sheriff Joe Arpaio: Obama Identity Document Fraud Investigation Will Continue – 9/2/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,030 views
-
5:14
51
Rush Limbaugh: Birther Confession; Takes An American Comment; Sick Media
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,193 views
-
1:11
52
MSNBC Whines About Mitt Romney Throwing A Bone To Birthers In RNC Acceptance Speech
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,650 views
-
5:40
53
Rush Slams MSNBC’s Race-Baiting: It’s Now Racist To Say Birth Certificate, Chicago, Obama
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,822 views
-
3:32
54
Chris Matthews Ambushes Condoleezza Rice With Birther Question – 8/29/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,467 views
-
3:22
55
Rush Says The RNC Will Give Him Demerits For Mentioning Birth Certificate
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,788 views
-
4:53
56
Newt Gingrich Obliterates Race-Baiter And Birther Chris Matthews – 8/27/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,606 views
-
6:12
57
Birther Chris Matthews Unhinged: Attacks RNC Chair – 8/27/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,956 views
-
2:15
58
CNN’s Candy ‘Porky’ Crowley & RNC Chair On Romney Birth Certificate Joke
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,951 views
-
1:14
59
Democrats Misspell Birther Airplane Banner At Romney Event
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,111 views
-
3:21
60
Rush Doubles Down On Romney Birth Certificate Comment: Team Obama Responds
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,168 views
-
5:12
61
Rush: Romney Test Driving Obama Birth Certificate Issue; Right On, Right On!
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,066 views
-
0:43
62
Mitt Romney Goes Birther: Everyone Knows Where I Was Born
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,366 views
-
8:22
63
Birther Chris Matthews Attacks “Birther” Navy Seal For Practicing His 1st Amendment Right
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,359 views
-
15:00
64
Susan Daniels Explains Obama’s Connecticut Social Security Number And Zip Code Myth
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,874 views
-
13:03
66
P.I. Susan Daniels Discusses Lawsuit About Obama’s Connecticut Social Security Number
by BirtherReportDotCom 13,531 views
-
7:05
67
Left-Wing Nut Job Robert Gibbs Whines About Transparency and Donald Trump – 8/19/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,058 views
-
1:36
68
Obama Press Secretary Whines About Obama Eligibility Ad – 8/16/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 9,850 views
-
13:05
70
Obama Classmate The Scandal At Columbia That Ends The Obama Presidency
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,332 views
-
9:23
71
Obama Classmate Schools Geraldo Rivera About Obama’s Indonesian Name Barry Soetoro
by BirtherReportDotCom 26,318 views
-
1:21
72
Erick Erickson: Trump Should Focus On Obama’s College Records; Full WH Meltdown
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,599 views
-
4:31
73
Donald Trump: Obama’s Records May Reveal One Of The Great Cons Of All Time
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,675 views
-
6:40
74
Trump on Fox News’ Greta: Obama Needs To Release His Passport and College Records
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,480 views
-
8:47
75
Hannity with Obama Classmate: Breitbart Reporter Has Documented Proof Obama is Indonesian Citizen
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,681 views
-
7:46
76
Breitbart Reporter Charles Johnson Has Documented Proof Obama is Indonesian Citizen?
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,093 views
-
8:56
78
Breitbart Reporter in Indonesia Has Proof Obama is Indonesian Citizen
by BirtherReportDotCom 39,589 views
-
9:18
79
Rush Limbaugh: Obama Classmate; Obama Registered As Indonesian Citizen at Columbia University
by BirtherReportDotCom 14,796 views
-
4:56
80
Trump: Obama Spends Millions To Keep Passport Records and College Records Sealed
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,257 views
-
6:52
81
Team Obama Hypocrites Demand Romney Release Records: Obama’s Bogus Social Security Number Unanswered
by BirtherReportDotCom 767 views
-
3:55
82
Megadeth Founder Dave Mustaine: Obama Birth Certificate Fake; Why No Impeachment?
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,161 views
-
6:54
83
Ann Coulter: Unnamed Source In Kenya Says Obama Was Born In Kenya
by BirtherReportDotCom 20,190 views
-
10:00
84
Rush: Obama Lowest Grades At Harvard; Obama Release The Records; Burden of Proof On YOU
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,721 views
-
8:54
85
Rush Limbaugh to Ancestry.com: Find Obama’s College Transcripts and Birth Certificate
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,683 views
-
2:31
86
Congressman Steve King Addresses Obama’s Eligibility: Says They Will Deal With It After Election
by BirtherReportDotCom 10,055 views
-
5:10
87
Brian Williams Presses Romney’s Tax Returns and Hidden Past: Ignores Obama’s Identity Document Fraud
by BirtherReportDotCom 1,286 views
-
11:59
89
Sheriff Joe’s Lead Investigator: Obama’s Birth Certificate Cannot Survive Judicial Scrutiny
by BirtherReportDotCom 5,099 views
-
15:00
90
Donald Trump Forces Sean Hannity to Address Obama’s Forged Birth Certificate – 7/18/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 57,104 views
-
13:09
91
Mike Zullo and Mara Zebest Discuss Obama’s Forged Birth Certificate – 7/18/2012
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,709 views
-
9:43
92
Washington Times’ Jeff Kuhner Blasts Obama’s Hypocrisy; Obama’s Sealed Records
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,640 views
-
2:35
93
Rush Limbaugh: Ice Cream Parlors and Obama’s Kenyan Relatives
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,097 views
-
29:42
94
Author Jack Cashill Takes On Pro-Obama Author David Maraniss’ New Obama Book
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,451 views
-
1:24
95
NBC’s WPTV-5: Florida Obama Ballot Access Challenge Hearing Coverage
by BirtherReportDotCom 6,043 views
-
8:22
96
Arizona SoS Ken Bennett Believes Obama Fibbed Birthplace for College; All Records Sealed
by BirtherReportDotCom 7,792 views
-
19:11
97
Author Tom Ballantyne Interviews Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s Lead Obama Investigator Mike Zullo
by BirtherReportDotCom 3,640 views
-
7:42
98
Attorney and San Diego Superior Court Judge Candidate Gary Kreep Talks Obama Eligibility
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,868 views
-
39:24
99
Diana West and Peter Boyles Talk Obama’s Felony Identity Document Fraud and Media Silence
by BirtherReportDotCom 2,467 views
-
11:08
100
Sheriff Joe in Las Vegas: Obama Identity Document Fraud; Criminal Investigation
by BirtherReportDotCom 4,901 views
-
53:21
101
Diana West Discusses Obama’s Forged Birth Certificate and Forged Selective Service Registration Card
by BirtherReportDotCom 12,509 views
-
26:25
102
ICE Agent Explains Obama’s Social Security Number Reserved for Connecticut Applicants
by BirtherReportDotCom 25,710 views